+3
Luckstar
Marrillian
Faye Fang Kaew
7 posters
Card specific rulings
Faye Fang Kaew- Posts : 531
Reputation : 10
Timezone : MST/MDT
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°26
Re: Card specific rulings
Yes.
Marrillian- Posts : 1304
Reputation : 5
Timezone : Hidden
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°27
Re: Card specific rulings
Thanks... I feel like I am the only one with ruling questions
Luckstar- Posts : 543
Reputation : 1
Timezone : GMT+8
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°28
Re: Card specific rulings
Ok..I have one question. Someone told me in a duel that E-Hero Prisma's eff to reveal a Fusion monster on Extra can't work on Omni-Fusion monsters like The Shining and Absolute Zero, thus I can't send a Fusion Material Monster from my deck to grave. Is he really right?
StalkerSam- Posts : 188
Reputation : 1
Timezone : PARTY TIME
Software :- Duelling Network
- Other
- Post n°29
Re: Card specific rulings
Yes , since the materials aren't specified.
quick question:-
if i activate pot of duality , can i fusion summon (either using power bond , miracle fusion).
quick question:-
if i activate pot of duality , can i fusion summon (either using power bond , miracle fusion).
DuelLegend- Posts : 1489
Reputation : 8
Timezone : GMT +0
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°30
Re: Card specific rulings
No. Fusion summon is an SS.
(do correct me if I am wrong but this is what I thought seeing as fusions are not normal summons)
(do correct me if I am wrong but this is what I thought seeing as fusions are not normal summons)
StalkerSam- Posts : 188
Reputation : 1
Timezone : PARTY TIME
Software :- Duelling Network
- Other
- Post n°31
Re: Card specific rulings
if you ever notice decks that focus on fusions have x3 dualitys , plus on YGOpro it used to work ( the system is automated , no cheating or manually doing it)..that's what confuses me about this...
Faye Fang Kaew- Posts : 531
Reputation : 10
Timezone : MST/MDT
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°32
Re: Card specific rulings
No you can't. The only decks that really focus on fusions is Heros and most Hero decks run low monsters, hence the Dualities.
StalkerSam- Posts : 188
Reputation : 1
Timezone : PARTY TIME
Software :- Duelling Network
- Other
- Post n°33
Re: Card specific rulings
ahh good to know , seems like pro made a mistake xD
Marrillian- Posts : 1304
Reputation : 5
Timezone : Hidden
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°34
Re: Card specific rulings
The "Hex" monsters say they can be used as a substitute for one material in a fusion. Does this apply always? Examples. The light hex and Chimertech (the one that does not need poly) can I use the light hex as a cyber dragon? Then in the grave, using overload fusion, can I use the hex as a cyber?
Faye Fang Kaew- Posts : 531
Reputation : 10
Timezone : MST/MDT
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°35
Re: Card specific rulings
If you could use it in the first instance, you can use it in the second.
Marrillian- Posts : 1304
Reputation : 5
Timezone : Hidden
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°36
Re: Card specific rulings
If I summon Lightpulsar Dragon and my opponent uses bottumless trap hole, do I get to special summon a Red-Eyes Darkness Metal Dragon from my grave?
Faye Fang Kaew- Posts : 531
Reputation : 10
Timezone : MST/MDT
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°37
Re: Card specific rulings
No.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°38
Re: Card specific rulings
Something I've been wondering, and the local judge hasn't been able to answer.
Infected Mail + Gladiator Beasts
Does the GB return to the deck via it's effect, or is it destroyed? I've assumed the former, but, for all I know, is the latter.
Infected Mail + Gladiator Beasts
Does the GB return to the deck via it's effect, or is it destroyed? I've assumed the former, but, for all I know, is the latter.
Faye Fang Kaew- Posts : 531
Reputation : 10
Timezone : MST/MDT
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°39
Re: Card specific rulings
You can return them before they are destroyed.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°40
Re: Card specific rulings
I remember waybackwhen reading about the fact that if a monster has its effect negated, either whilst on the field or in the grave, if it is summoned onto the field again in some manner, it is "cleansed" of the negating effect, and thus, has its effect again, because it's counting as a "new" one of itself. As in, if I summon Gellenduo and its effect gets negated and it dies, if I monster reborn it, that Gellenduo is now a "new" Gellenduo, and no longer is negated.
Is this correct? Because I'm having trouble finding a ruling saying so. Yet I remember having seen one some time ago.
Is this correct? Because I'm having trouble finding a ruling saying so. Yet I remember having seen one some time ago.
DuelLegend- Posts : 1489
Reputation : 8
Timezone : GMT +0
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°41
Re: Card specific rulings
That is correct, but it depends on the negation effect. If it is a continuious Skill Drain, no. If it's a veiler, yes.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°42
Re: Card specific rulings
Tsukiyo Kenso wrote:I remember waybackwhen reading about the fact that if a monster has its effect negated, either whilst on the field or in the grave, if it is summoned onto the field again in some manner, it is "cleansed" of the negating effect, and thus, has its effect again, because it's counting as a "new" one of itself. As in, if I summon Gellenduo and its effect gets negated and it dies, if I monster reborn it, that Gellenduo is now a "new" Gellenduo, and no longer is negated.
Is this correct? Because I'm having trouble finding a ruling saying so. Yet I remember having seen one some time ago.
it depends on the card negating and depends on the monster negated. usually u are correct. if it leaves the field then comes back u can use the effect again
DuelLegend- Posts : 1489
Reputation : 8
Timezone : GMT +0
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°43
Re: Card specific rulings
DuelLegend wrote:That is correct, but it depends on the negation effect. If it is a continuious Skill Drain, no. If it's a veiler, yes.
Spirit_Of_Sun wrote:
it depends on the card negating and depends on the monster negated. usually u are correct. if it leaves the field then comes back u can use the effect again
Beat you
Guest- Guest
- Post n°44
Re: Card specific rulings
It was Veiler specifically that I was referring to.
Also, just for gits and shiggles, I think I should bring up the rulings on Stardust Dragon I saw. So he apparently can never return after using his negating effect if summoned by Starlight Road, right? I find this /extremely/ weird, only because nowhere in his card does it say he has to be successfully synchro summoned for his effect to take place. I mean, if he removes himself from the field as a cost, would that not, in some way, "reset" the fact that he wasn't synchro summoned and thus make him able to come back...? Apparently not going by the ruling. But what if one Monster Reborns him whilst he's in the grave passed that?
I was speaking with my friend about this ruling, and our guess is that you can't even reborn him, since you can't use Call of the Haunted on him after that either. This makes Starlight Road one of the most confusing cards I've ever seen. lol Only because there's no way to know by understanding of mechanics of the game that this is the ruling. You just have to KNOW the ruling. Otherwise, you'd never figure it out. lol Unlike how I can know that, say, Geartown does not activate if destroyed at a chain link other than 1, just like how Fortune Lady Light would miss timing if not removed at chain link 1. That's an understanding I can reach just by knowing the mechanics of the game, to give a comparison.
Also, just for gits and shiggles, I think I should bring up the rulings on Stardust Dragon I saw. So he apparently can never return after using his negating effect if summoned by Starlight Road, right? I find this /extremely/ weird, only because nowhere in his card does it say he has to be successfully synchro summoned for his effect to take place. I mean, if he removes himself from the field as a cost, would that not, in some way, "reset" the fact that he wasn't synchro summoned and thus make him able to come back...? Apparently not going by the ruling. But what if one Monster Reborns him whilst he's in the grave passed that?
I was speaking with my friend about this ruling, and our guess is that you can't even reborn him, since you can't use Call of the Haunted on him after that either. This makes Starlight Road one of the most confusing cards I've ever seen. lol Only because there's no way to know by understanding of mechanics of the game that this is the ruling. You just have to KNOW the ruling. Otherwise, you'd never figure it out. lol Unlike how I can know that, say, Geartown does not activate if destroyed at a chain link other than 1, just like how Fortune Lady Light would miss timing if not removed at chain link 1. That's an understanding I can reach just by knowing the mechanics of the game, to give a comparison.
Faye Fang Kaew- Posts : 531
Reputation : 10
Timezone : MST/MDT
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°45
Re: Card specific rulings
Well, knowing the game mechanics would actually make you know the ruling. If a Fusion/Xyz/Synchro was not brought out properly they can't be revived.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°46
Re: Card specific rulings
Acacia wrote:Well, knowing the game mechanics would actually make you know the ruling. If a Fusion/Xyz/Synchro was not brought out properly they can't be revived.
Had no idea. One of the few mechanics I haven't encountered an problem with to then look up and learn how it actually goes.
Thank you for clarifying. That completely explains it.
Marrillian- Posts : 1304
Reputation : 5
Timezone : Hidden
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°47
Re: Card specific rulings
I have DNA surgery on the field, and my opponent has a card(s) that says "cannot be targeted by Spells, Traps, or card effects." Can I use that card(s) as a fusion material for Chimeratech Fortress Dragon?
DuelLegend- Posts : 1489
Reputation : 8
Timezone : GMT +0
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°48
Re: Card specific rulings
Yes. DNA Surgery doesn't target. Someone will however have to clarify if Poly, FF, Overload, Power Bond, etc target (though I don't think so?)
Marrillian- Posts : 1304
Reputation : 5
Timezone : Hidden
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°49
Re: Card specific rulings
That makes no difference in my case. I was referring to if these cards were on the other side of the field. Because now There are none of these stupid stall cards that will ruin my field.
Marrillian- Posts : 1304
Reputation : 5
Timezone : Hidden
Software :- Duelling Network
- Post n°50
Re: Card specific rulings
Does darkstorm dragon effect destroy zomma (and all those trap monsters) when they are in the monster zone?
|
|